Macro Makeover Club

Macro Makeover Club

A Blueberry Tart with 20g Protein a Slice

And only 250 calories...

Amy Schenker's avatar
Amy Schenker
Sep 06, 2026
∙ Paid

I eat dessert daily (and I know I’m not the only one) but if I ate ‘traditional’ high fat, high sugar desserts daily, a few things would happen:

  1. I wouldn’t feel my best. I often feel sick or sluggish after desserts like this, especially if eaten early in the day.

  2. I’d gain weight. Period. I allot roughly 200-300 calories for a small after lunch dessert (like a piece of dark chocolate, or a few gummies), and a slightly bigger one after dinner. If I were eating desserts that were 500-1000 calories (which most recipes I find online are), it would cause me to slowly, but surely gain weight.

  3. I probably wouldn’t enjoy it much. I just don’t really like super sweet desserts.

Thats why I make healthier and lower calorie (and sugar) desserts, usually with a protein boost.

They’re going to help me feel better overall, I’ll enjoy them more, and they’ll work WITH my goals, rather than against them while still feeling like iI’m not missing out on anything.

I started this Macro Makeover series because it’s important to have recipes that work with you, but don’t feel like your eating diet foods all the time.

Macro Makeover Club is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

The Swaps That Make it Possible

Light Cream Cheese Instead of Full Fat

While you can omit the cream cheese all together, it gives the filling that rich, tangy flavor and smooth, and creamy texture.
So instead of full fat, we’re using light cream cheese, which is one of my favorite ingredient swaps. You still get that cheesecake flavor, but with significantly fewer calories and less fat.

Honestly, it’s one of the easiest calories saving swaps you can make.

Greek Yogurt & Cottage Cheese for Extra Creaminess (and Protein!)

Instead of relying almost entirely on cream cheese, we’re replacing part of it with fat-free Greek yogurt and blended cottage cheese.

The Greek yogurt keeps the filling light, creamy, and tangy while the cottage cheese blends into an incredibly smooth, creamy texture reminiscent with cheesecake when mixed with the sweeteners.

Not only does this dramatically increase the protein, but it also allows us to cut back on calories without sacrificing that rich cheesecake consistency.

Zero Calorie Sweetener Instead of Sugar

This is one of the easiest places to save a lot of calories.
Instead of using regular sugar throughout the recipe, we’re using a powdered zero calorie sweetener. This is a swap I make in pretty much every recipe because it makes such a massive difference.

You still get a perfectly sweet cheesecake filling and blueberry topping, but without hundreds of calories coming from added sugar.

As always, sweeten to taste. Every sweetener is a little different, and your protein powder will be adding some sweetness too.

Protein Powder For Sweetness and Protein

Adding vanilla protein powder not only helps boost the protein, but also adds a little extra vanilla sweetness and body to the filling.

Just don’t overdo it. Too much protein powder can make cheesecake fillings dense or chalky, so I recommend starting with two scoops and adjusting if needed.

Additionally, the type of protein powder you use, WILL make a difference in your results. Some will come out too thin, others thick or grainy - but some- just right. Learn more about protein powders, including links to my recommendations, here.

Adding Chia to the Blueberries

The blueberry layer is already one of the lighter parts of the dessert, so we don’t need to reinvent it.
But, instead of making a traditional sugar loaded jam, we’re simply cooking fresh blueberries with a zero calorie sweetener, a little lemon juice, and chia seeds.

The chia naturally thickens the blueberries while adding extra fiber, making the filling even more satisfying. If you’d prefer a smoother, more traditional jam, you can swap the chia for a little cornstarch or arrowroot instead.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Amy Schenker.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Amy Schenker · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.