Macro Makeover Club

Macro Makeover Club

You Won’t Believe The Macros on This One..

Almost 20g of protein for a slice of moist cake...

Amy Schenker's avatar
Amy Schenker
Sep 04, 2026
∙ Paid

I’m a huge fan of protein banana breads. I usually whip one up just about every time i have overripe bananas that need to get used. (abut to make one today actually!)

But when I saw this completely drool-worthy salted banana cake on my feed, I wanted to switch gears and make the cake instead.

But then I looked at the recipe…

I ran the macros, and it was OVER 1,000 calories and 124g of sugar PER PIECE.

I knew there HAD to be a better way…

So I made it!

I brought the calories down to 310, the sugar down to 12g (all natural!) all while more than doubling the protein, and keeping the same delicious, fluffy and decadent cake.

And honestly, I even amazed myself with how good this came out when making such a massive macro transformation.

Here’s some of the swaps that made it possible:

Swapping Out the Sugar

This is something I do in basically every recipe. The original version called for over 6 cups of sugar which is THOUSANDS of calories, so replacing it with zero calorie sweeteners was a no-brainer.

And between the banana and other sweeteners, honestly, I also didn’t think it needed 6 cups of sugar anyway...

Replacing Some of the Butter

Another common swap is use in my baking is replacing butter for greek yogurt.

Not only does this keep the moist texture, but also gives you a protein boost, and reduces the calories. This is another swap I live by in my baked goods, but when I’m testing Macro Makeover’s like this, I usually keep some of the butter, just in case.

Adding Protein Powder

Protein powder in baking can do a few different things:

  • Depending on the type, it can be a 1:1 swap for part of your flour, increasing the protein.

  • For things like frostings, it can act as a thickener, but this again, depends on the type. some can do the opposite or come out grainy.

  • Obviously, it adds a protein boost. Paired with a cup of greek yogurt and some berries, you could absolutely eat this cake for breakfast (in fat- I did!)

  • It also adds sweetness, without having to add additional sugar

Highly recommend reviewing this article I wrote about how different protein powders can vary in recipes, including my recommendations for baking.

Using Dates for Caramel

This recipe called for a caramel swirl - and caramel is essentially just sugar and butter-but I knew I could make something that tastes extremely similar, with dates. And to be honest, to make the process even easier- you can even just used date paste!

Dates mimic a caramel flavor, while providing you a natural sweetness.

Ingredients:

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Amy Schenker.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Amy Schenker · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.